Discounts Delivered to your Inbox!  E-mail:                   

|

McGuillicuddy's New Paltz NY
84 Main St., New Paltz , NY   12561    
845-256-9289        Email:  richsormby@gmail.com

Website:  http://www.CuddysNY.com


 Create an Account or Login
(What's This?)

     

Just show your "Discount Card" to take Advantage of these Great Deals!
Be sure to check back for new offers!

.

20% off of lunch until 4 pm. Not valid with any specials


russet light raw umber marble divider

MENU
Print Version

Food Menu

Appetizers

Chicken Tenders
$6.95

Crispy fried chicken tenders served with your choice of BBQ sauce or honey mustard. Also available tossed in any of delicious wing sauces for $1.00 extra.

Cuddy's Sliders
$7.50

Three mini cheeseburgers with lettuce & tomato

Irish Nachos
$8.50

Waffle fries topped with bacon and melted cheese. Served with a side of ranch.

Nachos
$9.50

Tortilla chips with beef, chicken, or veggies, topped with cheddar jack cheese, tomato, red onion, shredded lettuce, and sour cream. Served with a side of salsa.

Pulled Pork Slammers
$7.50

Three mini pulled pork sandwiches.

Veggie Platter
$8.95

A platter of celery, carrots, broccoli, cucumbers, tomatoes, and toasted pita bread. Served with your choice of bleu cheese, ranch dressing, or hummus.

Chicken and Spinach Dip
$8.50

A warm, creamy blend of spinach and chicken, with melted cheddar jack cheese. Served in a toasted bread bowl.

Irish Egg Rolls
$6.95

Egg rolls full of fresh corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and thousand island dressing.

Mac and Cheese Bites
$6.95

Fried macaroni and pepper jack cheese bites.

Potato Boats
$6.95

Potato skins (4) topped with bacon and melted cheddar jack cheese. Served with sour cream.

Quesadilla
$7.95

Chicken, beef, or veggie available. Served with sour cream and salsa.

Baskets

Frickles
$6.95

Breaded, deep fried pickle spears.
Served with a side of cajun ranch.

French Fries
$4.95

Crispy, golden brown french fries.

Sweet Potato Fries
$5.95

Crispy, flavorful sweet potato fries.

Tenders and Fries
$6.95

Chicken tenders (3) and a half portion of fries.

Waffle Fries
$5.95

Crispy, flavorful waffle fries.

Onion Petals
$5.95

Deep fried, crispy onion petals.

World of Wings

Boneless Wings
$6.95

10 boneless wings, tossed in any of these great sauces.

Red Hot BBQ
$7.95

Very hot - BBQ sauce style wing with a serious kick!

Inferno (Very Hot Buffalo Style)
$7.95

Very hot, buffalo style wing sauce.

Habanero Honey Buffalo
$7.95

Our signature honey buffalo sauce with an added habanero pepper kick.

Volcanic (Medium Buffalo Style)
$7.95

Buffalo style medium sauce.

Honey Buffalo
$7.95

Sweet and spicy, full of flavor!
Our medium sauce mixed with honey.

Cajun Spice (Dry Rub)
$7.95

Cajun seasoning flavored wing.

Jamaican Jerk (Dry Rub)
$7.95

Jamaican jerk seasoning.

Buttery Lemon Pepper
$7.95

Lemon pepper seasoning mixed with a small amount of butter.

Teriyaki
$7.95

Traditional teriyaki sauce.

General Tzo
$7.95

Classic general tzo sauce, sweet with no kick.

Salt and Vinegar
$7.95

Just like the chips! An instant classic.

Garlic Parmesan
$7.95

A delicious sauce of garlic mixed with just the right amount of parmesan.

Naked
$7.95

Plain wings, no sauce.

Pepper Spray
$7.95

Our hottest wing flavor. Good luck!

Gold Fever
$7.95

Very hot - gold rush style sauce with a serious kick!

3 Alarm (Hot Buffalo Style)
$7.95

Buffalo style hot sauce.

Brazilian Fire Rub (Dry Rub)
$7.95

Spicy dry rub wing, full of flavor.

Smoldering (Mild)
$7.95

Buffalo style mild sauce.

Sweet Heat BBQ
$7.95

Provides the sweetness of BBQ with the comfort of buffalo sauce.

Enchilada Sauce
$7.95

Taco inspired wing, with a dash of buffalo sauce mixed in.

Sweet Thai Chili
$7.95

Full flavor thai chili sauce.

Bourbon
$7.95

On the sweeter side, full of flavor and no kick.

Hawaiian
$7.95

Teriyaki and pineapple flavor.

Gold Rush
$7.95

Tangy, honey mustard style BBQ sauce.

Garlic
$7.95

Top your wings with some delicious chopped garlic mixed with a small amount of butter.

Honey BBQ
$7.95

Tangy BBQ sauce mixed with the sweetness of honey.

Soups

Irish Potato Soup
$4.95

Rich and creamy, full of potatoes and bacon.

French Onion
$4.95

Delicious onion soup topped with french bread and a three cheese melt.

Specialty Soup
$4.95

Chef's choice!

911 Chili
$5.95

Hot and spicy beef chili topped with cheese, sour cream, and tortilla chips.

Salads

The Big Salad
$6.50

Mixed greens, broccoli, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, olives, and croutons. 
Add grilled chicken $3.95; Add grilled shrimp or steak $4.95; Add grilled salmon $5.95

Buffalo Chicken Salad
$9.50

Crispy buffalo chicken served on a bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes and crumbled bleu cheese.

Dressing Choices
$0.00

Italian, honey dijon, bleu cheese, thousand island, balsamic vinaigrette, raspberry vinaigrette, caesar, or ranch.

Caesar Salad
$6.50

Fresh, crispy romaine lettuce topped with croutons and parmesan cheese. 
Add grilled chicken $3.95; Add grilled shrimp or steak $4.95; Add grilled salmon $5.95

Taco Salad
$9.95

Your choice of chicken or ground beef over lettuce in a crispy tortilla bowl with olives, tomatoes, jalapenos, and onions. Topped with Fresh corn salsa and cheddar jack cheese. Served with cajun ranch dressing.

Burger Board

All burgers are served on an egg twist roll with lettuce, tomato, and pickle along with your choice of side.

Build-A-Burger
$8.95

Start with our 9 oz. burger, pick your own cheese or one topping. Add any additional toppings you'd like!

The Del Monaco
$12.95

Our 9 oz. hand packed burger, topped with philly cheese steak, sauteed onions, and american cheese.

Veggie Burger
$8.95

Our signature veggie burger, topped with your choice of cheese or one topping.

Sides
$0.00

French fries, rice pilaf, caesar salad, house salad, baked potato, mashed potato.
Waffle fries ($1.00 extra), onion petals ($1.00 extra), sweet potato fries ($1.00 extra).

Cowboy Burger
$9.95

9 oz. hand packed burger, topped with cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, and deep fried onion petals.

Turkey Burger
$8.95

Flavorful turkey burger, topped with your choice of cheese or one topping.

Toppings List (First Topping Included)
$0.95

American cheese, swiss cheese, cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese, pepper jack cheese, crumbled bleu cheese, bacon, mushrooms, raw onions, sauteed onions, roasted red peppers, sweet peppers, jalapenos, BBQ sauce. 
Top your burger with chili for $1.50

Sandwiches

All sandwiches are served with a pickle and your choice of side.

Fresh Corned Beef
$8.95

Our house-made corned beef with swiss cheese. 
Served on your choice of white, wheat, rye, or an egg twist roll.

Bourbon Chicken Sandwich
$8.95

Grilled chicken breast with bourbon sauce, sauteed onions, and mushrooms.
Served on an egg twist roll with lettuce and tomato.

BBQ Beast
$8.95

Tangy BBQ pulled pork sandwich. Served on an egg twist roll. 
Add cheddar cheese for $1.00

Philly Cheese Steak
$8.95

Thinly sliced steak with sauteed onions and melted american cheese.
Served on a club roll.

Chicken Ranchero Wrap
$8.95

Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, and ranch dressing.
Served in a garlic herb wrap.

Veggie Wrap
$8.95

Roasted red peppers, red onion, and zucchini, with lettuce, hummus, and jalapeno crunchers.
Served in a garlic herb wrap.

Sides
$0.00

French fries, rice pilaf, caesar salad, house salad, baked potato, mashed potato.
Waffle fries ($1.00 extra), onion petals ($1.00 extra), sweet potato fries ($1.00 extra).

Corned Beef Reuben
$9.95

Our house-made corned beef, with sauerkraut, and swiss cheese, topped with thousand island dressing.
Served on grilled rye bread.

Chicken Club
$8.95

Grilled chicken breast with bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
Served on an egg twist roll with a side of mayo.
Also available cajun or buffalo style.

Cajun Roast Beef Melt
$8.95

Cajun grilled roast beef with bacon and melted cheddar.
Served on an egg twist roll with lettuce and tomato.

McGillicuddy's Steak Sandwich
$10.95

8oz. sirloin steak with peppers, onions, and mushrooms. Topped with melted cheddar jack cheese and steak sauce.
Served on a club roll.

Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$8.95

Crispy buffalo style chicken with lettuce, tomato, and bleu cheese dressing.
Served in a garlic herb wrap.

Chicken Caesar Wrap
$8.95

Grilled chicken with crispy romaine lettuce, and caesar dressing.
Served in a garlic herb wrap.

Paninis

All paninis are served with a pickle and your choice of side.

Chicken Godfather Panini
$9.95

Crispy chicken tenders, fresh garlic, chopped tomato, and mozzarella cheese.

Turkey Club Panini
$9.95

Grilled turkey breast, bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, and tomato.

Southwest Chicken Panini
$9.95

Grilled chicken, pepper jack cheese, and sweet pepper strips topped with guacamole and taco sauce.

Roast Beef Panini
$9.95

Grilled roast beef, carmelized onions, and swiss cheese.
Served with a side of gravy.

Veggie Panini
$9.95

Grilled portabella mushrooms, red onions, roasted red peppers, and pepper jack cheese
Topped with a balsamic glaze.

Sides
$0.00

French fries, rice pilaf, caesar salad, house salad, baked potato, mashed potato.
Waffle fries ($1.00 extra), onion petals ($1.00 extra), sweet potato fries ($1.00 extra).

Cuddy's Favorites

Shepherd's Pie
$10.95

A blend of beef, veggies, and mashed potatoes.
Topped with cheddar jack cheese and gravy.

Hot Open Turkey
$9.95

Fresh made turkey, served open faced on toast with gravy and your choice of side.

Fish and Chips
$9.95

Homemade, beer battered cod and potato wedges.
Served with a side of tartar sauce.

Gourmet Mac & Cheese
$8.95

A gourmet blend of smoked gouda, colby jack, and sharp cheddar cheese, topped with fresh bread crumbs and parmesan cheese.
Add chopped bacon for $1.50

Fajitas

Served with shredded cheddar jack cheese, lettuce, salsa, and sour cream. Add guacamole for 95 cents.

Veggie Fajita
$11.95

Grilled portabella mushrooms, broccoli, olives, and tomatoes, with peppers, onions, and teriyaki sauce.

Steak Fajita
$12.95

Charbroiled strips of steak with peppers, onions, and teriyaki sauce.

The Two Way Fajita
$14.95

Your choice of any combination.

Chicken Fajita
$11.95

Grilled chicken strips with peppers, onions, and teriyaki sauce.

Shrimp Fajita
$13.95

Grilled jumbo shrimp, with peppers, onions, and teriyaki sauce.

Pastas

Served with a side salad.

Cajun Shrimp Broccoli Alfredo
$15.95

Shrimp and broccoli over a thin linguine.
All tossed in a cajun alfredo sauce.

Taco Pasta
$13.95

Sauteed premium ground beef, mixed with sauteed onions and peppers in a taco inspired red sauce, over penne pasta.
Topped with corn salsa, sour cream, and corn chips.

Four Cheese Pasta Bake
$14.95

Sauteed chicken breast, garlic, and tomato.
All baked in a four cheese sauce with penne pasta.

Penne A La Vodka
$12.95

Our special vodka sauce with pancetta.
Add chicken for $3.95. Also available vegetarian style.

Entrees

Served with a side salad.

New York Sirloin
$16.95

12 oz. choice cut, grilled to your liking.
Served with vegetables and a side of your choice.

Lemon Chicken
$15.95

Two sauteed chicken breasts, in a light, buttery, lemon-dill sauce.
Served on a bed of pasta or with rice and veggies.

Sides
$0.00

French fries, rice pilaf, caesar salad, house salad, baked potato, mashed potato.
Waffle fries ($1.00 extra), onion petals ($1.00 extra), sweet potato fries ($1.00 extra).

Cilantro Lime Salmon
$16.95

Norwegian salmon, served baked or pan seared,
topped with a light, cilantro lime cream sauce.
Served with vegetables and your choice of side.

Chicken Marsala
$15.95

Two sauteed chicken breasts, in a traditional marsala cream sauce with portabella mushrooms, over a bed of rice.
Served with a side of vegetables.

Kids Menu

Available for all children 12 and under. All kids meals served in a boat and come with a toy from the McGillicuddy's Treasure Chest! All Kids Meals Served with your choice of Fresh Fruit Salad or French Fries

Kid Burger
$4.95

Burger with French Fries or Fresh Fruit Salad.

Say Cheese!
$4.50

Grilled Cheese Sandwich with French Fries or Fresh Fruit Salad.

Kid Pasta
$3.95

A Bowl of Pasta with your choice of Butter or Marinara.

Chicken Little
$4.95

Chicken Fingers or Grilled Chicken Served with French Fries or Fresh Fruit Salad.

Wing Ding
$4.95

Five Plain Chicken Wings with French Fries of Fresh Fruit Salad. (Wing Sauces Available or Available on the Side as well.)

Hot Diggity Dog
$3.95

Hot Dog with French Fries or Fresh Fruit Salad.

russet light raw umber marble divider